BRIGHTON PIZZA RANKED: FOUR SLICES ONE CLEAR WINNER
Which slice deserves your money?
Brighton has a lot of pizza so four options were judged side by side Detroit style deep dish, a large market slice, a traditional round pizza and a £2 pepperoni slice that tasted bad. Each was scored on taste, dough, sauce, cheese, toppings and value for money.
The results reflect the writer’s reported visits and opinions. Prices and restaurant details have not been independently verified.
1. DETROIT PIZZA CLUB THE CLEAR WINNER
1. DETROIT PIZZA CLUB THE CLEAR WINNER
Detroit style deep pan pizza from Kemptown /St James’s Street, with thick square cut portions and a price of approximately £20. The base is smoky, crunchy and soft inside with a warm bread texture. Generous toppings are the standout strength, while the sauce is balanced and the cheese is cool. The big ass pizza is very filling, so I would recommend sharing. Also, if you wanted a very different experience from other shacks like pizza places, I would highly recommend this location. I have also been here before, and I have never had a bad pizza from this location.
Value: Expensive, but easier to justify when the thick portions are shared. Verdict: The clear winner for distinctive flavour, dough and toppings.
2. TONY’S OPEN PIZZA THE BEST CHEAPER ALTERNATIVE
This Brighton Open Market slice is large New York inspired and priced at £4.50. Crunchy, well cooked dough supports pepperoni parmesan and basil creating a balanced and flavourful combination. The tomato flavour is noticeable even though the sauce is not prominent and the cheese is less greasy than expected. a convincing, flavourful slice when you want good pizza without a large spend. can also get a whole pizza but they call them pies for £20
Value: The large portion, flavour and texture make £4.50 the strongest quality price balance.
Verdict: A satisfying slice and the best cheaper alternative.
3. Brighton PIZZA & CHICKEN LONDON ROAD
3. Brighton PIZZA & CHICKEN LONDON ROAD
This London Road takeaway serves traditional round 10 inch pizzas alongside chicken goes with the name i guess. At around £5 it would get you a whole pizza with soft dough, generous sauce and decent toppings. The sticky cheese was difficult to eat easy , and the toppings were less distinctive than Tony’s but the portion and price remain practical. A practical whole pizza choice, with good value offset by sticky cheese and weaker toppings.
Value: The large portion, flavour and texture make £4.50 the strongest quality price balance.
Verdict: A satisfying slice and the best cheaper alternative.
4. MET COLLEGE PIZZA
4. MET COLLEGE PIZZA
At £2 it was the cheapest option but the slice was greasy, the crunchy dough lacked flavour and the sauce was almost absent. Salty, low flavour pepperoni did little to help the cheese was the best element though still just bad. Cheap, but the grease, bland dough, weak sauce and low impact toppings leave too many compromises.
Value: The £2 price earns some credit, but the small portion and weak flavour make it a compromise rather than a bargain.
Verdict: The ranking’s biggest disappointment. but still worth it if on a low budget
THE FINAL BRIGHTON PIZZA RANKINGS
THE FINAL BRIGHTON PIZZA RANKINGS
Detroit Pizza Club leads clearly, while Tony’s Open Pizza and Pizza & Chicken provide more accessible meals. College Pizza trails because its low price does not overcome the lack of flavour.
Scores are reported opinions rather than independently verified ratings. Toppings and Value are separate categories.
SO WHICH BRIGHTON PIZZA SHOULD YOU CHOOSE?
Detroit Pizza Club is the best overall choice for smoky sourdough flavour, a thick crunchy base and excellent toppings. Tony’s Open Pizza is the best cheaper alternative at £4.50. Pizza & Chicken London Road is a practical affordable whole pizza while College Pizza is best avoided unless price is the only priority.


